MyFox
 

The MoJo Prof

by bentleycl from Columbia

Last Post 27 days, 17 hours Ago


I need a little help again from my favorite set of bloggers.

Missouri journalists are in the midst of a rather divisive discussion over the credibility of blogs and comments on news sites that are signed only with screen names.  You know the drill, as most of the blogs here are signed with a name like, well, MoJo Prof.  Now those same Web identities are coming in on the comments sent to newspapers and broadcast Websites.

Traditionally, newspapers only run content authored by identifiable people who use their real names, so they won't run the anonymous comments.  But increasingly, people say they prefer a pseudonym. Some want to keep their opinions from their employers and neighbors.  Some say it gives them the emotional freedom to speak out.  Others just think it is cool.

The states editors are getting heartburn.

The Missouri School of Journalism has an obligation to help the media understand what you want.  And guess who was drafted to answer the questions of the state's editors?

I know we have been through this before, but please, please help your befuddled Missouri media wonks with some fresh and insightful comments. It's the editors in smaller cities who are most desperate for your views. I may have the journalism degree, but you have the expertise in blogging.

  • So how credible are anonymous comments?
  • Ditto blogs
  • Why don't you use your real name? 
  • And just as an aside, how do people choose their pen names?

Let me know by commenting on this post or sending an email to me at bentleycl@missouri.edu.  I will pass your insights to the editors and then let you know what they said.

The MoJo Prof

aka Clyde Bentley

Associate Professor

Missouri School of Journalism

24 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 24
Page 1 of 2
1
Last
dannbetty read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 11:15 AM

Any blog or editorial comment made under a pseudonym, if it is reported on should state clearly its source as anonymous or psuedo. Sometimes in order to get a rise, or make an attempt at humor, people will rely on this alter-ego to say things that can't be said, or they would be uncomfortable with under normal circumstance. They should never be taken as credible by serious journalist. That being said, I don't mind saying there are a fair share of them I don't take as credible or serious. Also the numbers of the opinions one way or the other are too easily altered by those who use more than one name.
I use my name in conjunction with my wife's out of laziness mostly, it's never been refused as belonging to a previous subscriber, and I don't want try to remember who else I might be, leads to schizomania.

mincooper read my blog
Jul 9, 2008 | 11:36 AM

I think there are a few reasons-
privacy could be one. Another is that the person really is wanting to be rude and feels doing so under a ficticious name will allow this. Also along the same line, are they really be honest when they use a fake name? Some may and others may not. At a few places I have worked part time, I have used an anonymous name to send an email to a high up official in the company, sometimes it has worked other times it has not.

VBallR read my blog
Jul 9, 2008 | 12:25 PM

I don't use my real name because I'm supposed to be working, not blogging.

I chose VBallR because I am an avid VolleyBall playeR.

snoopydad24 read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 1:13 PM

My reason to use an alias is privacy as well. Even when posting on PubDef I used an alias. It seems some people like to force their opinion on you when you disagree with them.

Plus my Principal wants us to be mindless workerbees except when he wants something. We are not suppose to be expressing our views especially in a public forum because he is afraid it will make him look bad. Yes he is very insecure and thinks everyone is out to get him. For me I just do my job – well except for this past school year when I had an unexpected sabbatical.

Flaglady read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 2:18 PM

I use to pass out business cards with my phone number to military families who had loved ones deployed. Some anti-war protestors got ahold of my info; called and harassed me. They finally tired of the game and quit. Would I ever give I personal info, even my name out again? I don't think so.

mr_wildflower read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 2:26 PM

I don't ever give personal advice.... I don't claim to know what I'm talking about..... I avoid sensitive issues and never want anybody to take what I say as a credible source.... Blogging to me is simply talking about current events and living life..... Therefore I don't care who knows who I am and have no need to be anonymous.... If I ever offend anybody I will apologise, but I do have an opinion and will state it......

Speedy62269 read my blog
Jul 9, 2008 | 3:00 PM

I treat blogs very similar how I take the news - I believe little. I guess one could ask if the National Enquirer is a reputable source.

Blogs are mainly for fun and conversation - especially at Fox 2. There are some national level blogs that actually have a particular subject being discussed and are frequented by true specialists.

If a person doesn't want my advice then ignore what I say and if you want to prosper because of a testimonial then share the wealth!

Tommy - I like your attitude!

Stlouisgreen read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 3:10 PM

Clyde, I would like to help you in pointing out to you that internet authors are not the first nor will they be the last to use fictious names when writing or saying things that others may or may not agree with. Ben Franklin used the pen name Richard Saunders to write the poor richards almanac and silence dogood for a series of letters that he wrote to the New England Courant. Then of course there was this little known man who wrote a few obscure american classics... Maybe you've read one... The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Tom Sawyer, or Life on the Mississippi that person was Samuel Clemens A.K.A Mark Twain

You see our media today just needs to know where to go to get to the bottom of the psuedo-identity crisis. A journalist only needs to do that which they learned how to in college, INVESTIGATE...

bentleycl read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 3:21 PM

Not to mention "Publius" (aka Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay), author of the Federalist Papers. Most newspaper editorials are unsigned, also.
Editors, however, worry about abuse of commentary from unidentified writers. They also tend to believe that the public, like journalists, place little credibility in anonymous writings. If that is the case, why publish them?
cb

Babujai read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 3:29 PM

I take anonymous/pseudo comments...as comments...not truth, just someone's opinion.

I use mine for privacy's sake. It's baby babble that became a nickname.

jeanette read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 8:45 PM

I use my real name. I to think some use an different name to be someone they would never be in person or to say thing's they would never say in person. Many different personality's.. Some as a privacy issue.
I too take comment's as comment not anything written in stone. I don't care what name anyone uses when writing.
But sometime's it make's me wonder who they are and are they alway's that unhappy with themselve's and their life.

FREEDOMFREE read my blog view my photos
Jul 9, 2008 | 9:58 PM

FREEDOM CHANGED HIS NAME FREE ,

TO FREE YOU FREE , AS YOU SEE ,

STAY TUNED , TO MYFOXTV .

Mutatis-Mutandis read my blog
Jul 9, 2008 | 11:07 PM

I use a pseudonym for several reasons. My real name is Matt Schneider. My main reason for using a different name is because I enjoy being someone else, if only by name. I like coming up with pseudonyms.

If someone took my blog and did not cite it as being from the Fox 2 blogger Mutatis-Mutandis, I would be immensly pissed off. Really, the only way I would be pissed is if someone took my words and claimed them as thier own.

I wouldn't take blogs for much credibility. That is why most of mine our purely opinoin pieces.

I got the name Mutatis-Muatndis from a Mudvayne song, and used it because I thought it sounded cool. Turns out Mutatis Muatndis is latin for "things ebing changed that needed to be changed" or something like that, and has often been used against me to paint me as the liberal elitist I obviously am.

mancillas read my blog
Jul 10, 2008 | 1:16 AM

To keep wierdo's like you out of my life! LOL

PS: Blogging does not change the world. It is simply a way to VENT. The FEW people that read the blogs on this site has no meaning.

mancillas read my blog
Jul 10, 2008 | 1:28 AM

Sorry, Harsh words.... But.. If you think about it, Blogs do not change a thing! I love to hear everyone's perspective on issues at hand...BUT.. What is typed here is read and forgotten!!

harp read my blog view my photos
Jul 10, 2008 | 7:01 AM

I think there nothing wrong with using a nickname or username...

I never sent anything to a newspaper or anything like that I only blog here and I don't read news paper only news I see here or on yahoo...

glasgowdug read my blog view my photos
Jul 10, 2008 | 8:52 AM

Anyone with a computer can blog so,..I don't give it too much credit. I've had some great conversations. I've met some great people. Some, very intelligent, some give their ignorance away rather quickly. Like Danbetty said, if a blog is going to be printed or repeated in any way it should be labeled properly.

Yeah, it's more fun to use a nickname. It's not like I'm trying to hide anything. You can usually go to person's profile and find out who they are, if you need to.

My name, glasgowdug is lame but it was the first one I came up with when I first joined the Seether message board 100 years ago, back when the internets began. (I just stuck with it)

memobo read my blog
Jul 10, 2008 | 11:57 AM

With identity theft at an all time high there is no way I would put any identifying info out there for anyone in cyberspace to see. I just don't trust the internet. I do realize that if I am engaged in "rude or improper" activity myfoxstl can cut me off or the FBI could track down who memobo really is. I accept that, but I'm not going to let just any Tom, Dick or Harry have my personal info or whereabouts.
I don't blog for statistical info or "facts". I blog for opinions and possible leads to answers to questions I may have and am researching. I don't take anything as gospel but its a good place to get another viewpoint.

mrmgrady read my blog view my photos
Jul 10, 2008 | 12:27 PM

Blogging can be one of two things:

1. Reporting events and/or information as they happened (or shortly thereafter).

2. Expressing one's viewpoint on a topic.

If a person is reporting events and/or information, it would be nice to know who they are and where they get their facts from (either from an independent source or from their own experience).

If they are expressing their opinion on some topic, they do not have to identify themselves (especially if it a controversial topic).

What we bloggers, writers and readers have to do in all instances are discern whether a post is a report or an opinion. The difference is a report is factual; the opinion is speculation on the part of the writer.

BTW, I use my real name, which may be dangerous since I do take on many controversial topics from time to time!

bentleycl read my blog view my photos
Jul 10, 2008 | 1:17 PM

If you were the editor of say, the Post-Dispatch, would you allow people to post replies and comments about editorials with just their screen names? One other option discussed is to require a real name, address and phone number to register, but then allow the "handle" in posts. Would you register?
Clyde

Page 1 of 2
1
Last


Write your comment below:




bentleycl

I'm an online-media professor at the Missouri School of Journalism. But I'm also a granddad, a letterboxer and an inept woodworker. I spent some time in the MyFox STL office and became hooked on the MyFox blogs. So here I am, sort of the voice of journalism with a big J. I'll take your criticism or answer your questions about the news, the media system or journalism of the future. If you are into the theoretical end of blogging, check my professional blog at http://thecyberbrains.com
.

Member Since: 5/25/2007