MyFox
 

The MoJo Prof

by bentleycl from Columbia

Last Post 27 days, 16 hours Ago


This week PBS asked me to guest-host its blog about online journalism.  I got to pontificate in MediaShift three times while host Mark Glaser was on vacation.

For the final post today, I talked about you.  Well, about what you have said to  me.  My post is about blog comments and their impact on traditional journalism.

If that link button above doesn't work, the site is http://www.pbs.org/mediashift.  Take a look.  And, of course, let me have it.

Clyde Bentley
The MoJo Prof
12 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 12
Page 1 of 1
jeanette read my blog view my photos
Nov 16, 2007 | 2:13 PM

The link worked.I am laughing.I didn't that is how they figured what to put on the community page.I thought it was because I had good blogs or they liked me.Wow you busted my bubble.Hey to do a blog you have to have thick skin sometimes.Well most the time but it is so much fun.Thanks for the link.

mr_wildflower read my blog view my photos
Nov 16, 2007 | 4:21 PM

Hey Clyde... Ive only got two words for you..............





Good Article.....!!

Cuteypops read my blog view my photos
Nov 16, 2007 | 6:37 PM

So basicly we have been guinia pigs all this time to help teach you students.

LadyCardFan read my blog view my photos
Nov 16, 2007 | 10:25 PM

Mojo . . . I somewhat disagree with you on who gets posted to the front page. While responses may be used as a "sometimes" gauge, it is not always the case. Content does matter as well. This is basically what I told one of your students when she informed us about number of responses over content. I didn't think it was fair of you to gauge only on responses. I've had my fair share of blogs appear on the main page (I think my high mark was 7 at once) and you can believe me, many did not get but a few responses.

Fox2 blogs, with the various categories to choose from, allow us the opportunity to be fun or serious, or seriously funny. But to say that the choice is made on number of responses is just downright incorrect. (May need to check with more than one source at Fox2).

BTW, I've enjoyed the student blogs who did not get a lot of responses.

old_as_the_superbowl read my blog view my photos
Nov 17, 2007 | 12:00 PM

I'm on board with you : )

jeepers4559 read my blog view my photos
Nov 18, 2007 | 10:48 AM

Nice article...and welcome to the other side of the veil. LOL

The beauty of the internet is that for the first time in history, an immediate response can be garnered instead of the occasional letter to the newspaper editor (perhaps censored, perhaps edited, perhaps completely ignored). What has always been an exercise in control, now cannot be controlled in the same way.

I'm sure that it's shocking to those who have been indeed, buffered from the clamouring crowd. Yes, the 'unwashed masses'...an idea which makes me belly laugh with glee. (In a good way...mostly.)

I can see you smiling from here. It does my heart good.

For the students, writing for writing's sake is only a small part of the puzzle. There has always been an audience, albeit usually much smaller. But when you write without response, your opinion exists in a vaccuum. Who are you actually writing for? And isn't the response you receive also part of the story? And if you're writing only for yourself, and are not interested in the response, what does that say?

rosie read my blog view my photos
Nov 18, 2007 | 5:55 PM

na na clydemyster, i've had blogs go up on the fronmnt page seconds after posting them. and ive comment on day old blogs from the front that never did get more then 2 or 3 comments in days

Stlouisgreen read my blog view my photos
Nov 19, 2007 | 5:42 PM

Much of the effect you are seeing in the number of blog comments is also demonstrated in the list alongside the persons post... I see that you have a number of favorite reads... And I would assume that on any given day you feel inclined to respond to at the very least one to three of them... given that 5 or more post a blog. This demonstrates that there are writers that elisit some kind of emotional response on a personal level and that you enjoy reading the material whether for entertainment or gleaning a piece of usable information... what ever the case it is not always the comments that drive the placement on a front community page but rather the content of the page itself.
I have been featured many times and recieved few comments on those blogs. Not because I did not invoke thought but because I did invoke it. Something to think about.

Weird read my blog view my photos
Nov 20, 2007 | 8:37 AM

Responses can be predicted immediately on mot blogs before anyone even reads them. A lengthy post will not get the attention that a short, concise one does. I currently have one written listing the top ten war profiteers which has to be long in order to get all of them included. People don`t want to read that long of a post. Our society has become one of instant gratification. If it can`t be done fast, we don`t do it. We have to have our microwaves instead of using a stove. We can`t obey the speed limits because we`re in too big of a hurry. Instead of reading, we buy books on tape and listen to them as we drive, which actually decreases your comprehension, since you`re weaving through cars that are driving the speed limit and your time is way too important to waste on legal speeds. Every day of your life that you don`t learn something new, you have wasted that day.

bentleycl read my blog view my photos
Nov 20, 2007 | 9:26 AM

Short posts, compelling posts, edgy posts -- I agree that all will generate comments. And that you can usually predict when they will.

The trouble in my profession is that journalists are very uncomfortable making or receiving comments. Witness that my original post to MediaShift has half as many comments as there are here. I had a couple off-line emails, however, from people who didn't want to comment in publicly.

You are all of the blog culture, and thank God for that. My job is to make my journalistic peers aware that this culture is as different from theirs as are the ethnic cultures we try to understand.

Clyde

mancillas read my blog
Nov 20, 2007 | 10:45 PM

If journalism is your profession, you get paid to write articles. You can get into trouble if you make an incorrect statement. You are paid to research and get the proper facts before you write an article, or suffer the consequences.

This is just like any business. For example: I am in real estate. I must research and know the information that I relay to the public.
If I give wrong information, I can be held accountable for this.

Blogging is not writing an article that people perceive as truth. It is simply "voicing your opinion." There is an expectation for other people to follow up and share how they feel about the topic being discussed. This helps the blogger to gain other people's perpectives on thier views to find different ways of coping with the things that bother them.

Why do you try to associate the two? Do you feel that blogging is taking away the future of journalism?

I am confused by this blog and would like to know just where you are coming from. Why would you make yourself out to be from "another culture"? Lower your brick wall that gives you a false feeling of being a better person, and let us help you with whatever is bothering you! You may find some friends who care. Think about it.

mancillas read my blog
Nov 20, 2007 | 10:48 PM

OH, and by the way... I can understand why you would receive less feedback on PBS. DUH

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




bentleycl

I'm an online-media professor at the Missouri School of Journalism. But I'm also a granddad, a letterboxer and an inept woodworker. I spent some time in the MyFox STL office and became hooked on the MyFox blogs. So here I am, sort of the voice of journalism with a big J. I'll take your criticism or answer your questions about the news, the media system or journalism of the future. If you are into the theoretical end of blogging, check my professional blog at http://thecyberbrains.com
.

Member Since: 5/25/2007